If you’ve ever eaten a handful of roasted peanuts and thought the extra dark ones were easily the tastiest, then this is the peanut butter for you. It’s made like any other natural peanut butter — it’s just peanuts and salt — except the peanuts are extra roasted for a richer, deeper flavor that is out-of-this-world good. It almost makes other peanut butters seem like they’ve forgotten what peanuts are supposed to taste like.

Dunk some apple slices into it, use it as the base for a Thai peanut sauce, spread it on a PB&J sandwich, or just eat it with a spoon. Whatever the case, I’m betting it’ll make your eyes roll into the back of your head with roasty toasty pleasure.

If you happen to live near a Kroger, I would check your local store first to get the best price, as this is their product brand. If you’re forced to shop online however, you can always head to Amazon and pick up a pack of two 16 oz jars for $40 or a pack of three for $49.